At this point, more than 2,000 students and faculty members have been arrested, often with disturbing force. Eyewitness reports and experiences of the brutality are incredibly valuable, and the hypocrisy with which some institutions promote past history of student activism as a marketing tool while cracking down on present student activism is breathtaking. It is a moment of crisis for higher education that has been years in the making, and it is our responsibility as faculty to demand accountability even as our work protecting peaceful student activism continues. All chapters and other organizational allies are invited to sign on to our statement from earlier this week, “In Defense of the Right to Free Speech and Peaceful Protest on University Campuses.”
The AAUP has been clear that antisemitism and hate have no place on our campuses or anywhere. On many campuses, criticism of a war and the policies of governments and institutions, including criticism by Jewish students, is being conflated with antisemitism. Suppressing speech or silencing peaceful protest in the name of safety is antithetical to the mission of higher education to promote free and open expression, inquiry, and debate. Administrators who immediately called in or allowed militarized law enforcement on campus to violently break up largely peaceful demonstrations failed completely in their duty to their students and their campus communities. We applaud institutions who worked with students to ensure that demonstrations would remain peaceful and educational. We are heartened to see agreements reached at Northwestern University, Brown University, Evergreen State College, and Rutgers University, where administrations listened to student concerns about how their institutions are implicated in world events and used negotiations as a tool of education to reach agreements. All of higher education will be watching to see that the agreements are followed.
A larger issue is the shameless and inappropriate pressure on university leaders by the nation’s politicians, by the universities’ most powerful donors, and by other interest groups aiming to shape higher education to a partisan political agenda. It is astonishing how quickly we have seen institutional leaders capitulate to that pressure and abandon the principles of shared governance and academic freedom that are necessary to protect colleges from outside influence and are largely responsible for the global preeminence of American higher education. At this critical time, the primary job for any college president is to provide a full-throated and robust defense of academic freedom for faculty and for the rights of free speech and freedom of assembly for all. If fundamental freedoms are not upheld in times of stress, then these freedoms do not exist.
If your AAUP chapter or faculty group has issued a statement or taken any action on these issues, we want to know about it. Please send your chapter’s statements, letters to the editor, resolutions, and the like to us at communications@aaup.org. We will collect and amplify our chapters’ work in order to connect us with each other’s good ideas and build solidarity. In addition, if you have thoughts to share with us on what would be particularly helpful to you or to the movement at this moment, send them to me at that address.
In solidarity,
Irene Mulvey
AAUP President